Between two evils by Eva Dolan
Zigic & Ferreira. Bloomsbury, 2020. ISBN: 9781408886441.
(Age: Senior secondary, Adult) Highly recommended. Between two evils
is the parallel stories of abuse. One takes place within the locked
precincts of a female immigration detention centre, the other
evolves from the overturning of a case of rape due to DNA evidence
being brought into question. DS Ferreire and DI Zigic are tested
ethically and morally as this team from Peterborough sort through a
maze of secretive bureaucracy and downright manipulation to get at
the truth and a conviction.
The murder of Dr. Joshua Ainsworth in his home just outside the
detention centre where he works in the medical clinic is brutal, and
it seems connected with his job. Ainsworth is an enigma. Some speak
highly of him, as a caring, ethical doctor working in a difficult
situation. Others, like the demonstrators outside the centre, see him
as part of an evil and repressive government regime. The privately
run Long Fleet detention centre was not exactly forthcoming with
information, putting a wall of data protection and privacy
legislation as excuses.
The other blow to the investigative team came when news broke that
Lee Walton a serial rapist and murderer had been released due to
problems with the examination of DNA evidence. It had been a long
and difficult case which now seemed all for nothing. But Walton then
begins to threaten Ferreire to reestablish his contacts with his
wife and son who had been moved away for their own protection.
It seems the only way to put Walton away is to reopen an old case. A
case which on the surface was watertight being finalised with a
confession. A confession that was given after a series of
interrogations by their current superior. A clandestine
investigation carried out without knowledge of most of the team and
always with the threat of it blowing up in their faces.
With the background of racism, bigotry and politics this is a story
of the present not just applicable to the United Kingdom and
Australia, but universally where conservatism and misplaced
nationalism are on the rise.
This is the first of Dolan's Ferreira and Zigic novels I have read.
There four others in the series; Long way home, Tell no
tales, After you die and Watch her disappear.
It may be helpful to have read others in giving a background to the
protagonists, which coming in cold did assume prior knowledge.
However Dolan's writing hauls you into the narrative and the 468
pages seem to fly by. Themes: Crime fiction, Detention centres,
Rape, DNA.
Mark Knight