Half bad by Sally Green
Penguin, 2104. ISBN: 9780141350868.
Themes: Good vs Evil; Witchcraft/Magic; Coming-of Age. The author
uses the Shakespearean quote from Hamlet, 'There is nothing either
good or bad, but thinking makes it so', as an opening epigraph. This
book is about witches - White or Black. The epigraph perhaps
introduces the idea that witches may be either good or bad depending
on how you view them. Perhaps setting aside the idea a 'rotten
apple' is rotten even if there are portions of it that look good,
this book focuses on the Witch world that lives alongside our own
'fain' world. The central character, Nathan, is in the unfortunate
position of living as a barely literate half-caste witch, but with
an extremely notorious absent father who is a Black Witch that has
been viewed badly by Nathan's own family and the wider White witch
community. The approaching Gifting ceremony to mark Nathan's passage
to Witch status at the age of 17 is the focus of the narrative and
its twists and curls. Magic is present, but almost understated. This
is a coming-of-age story, with family dramas involving abuse of the
one who doesn't fit the norm, a little forbidden romance, combined
with a quest to find the absentee father who deliberately remains in
obscurity. The book begins with short 'snapshot' chapters looking at
various circumstances of the captive life of the main character.
This is intriguing, but may create some confusion for an immature
reader. It does require a little persistence to reach the stage of
the book where the narrative becomes more straightforward and
chronological in its style. Perhaps this is part of the 'magic' of
the book.
I am sure this book will appeal to some in the YA female market. The
central character allows us to see the world through his eyes, and
consequently the abuse and hardships he suffers will elicit sympathy
in his female readers. A male readership may find the central
character to be too 'soft' and controlled in some of his responses
although there is still teenage/witch angst expressed.
As a reviewer I need to declare my Christian world view may have
tainted my impressions of this book. I have also resisted Twilight
reading or viewing and other Dark Worlds literature, so I came to a
book about Black and white witches and a central male character who
is Half black and Half white witch with some reservation. The
concept of evil, and how persuasive it can be, may be drawn from the
text. Even some of the 'good' characters and those in authority
(where power is corrupted for their own ends) cannot resist
inflicting hardship and violence on each other. The author does
temper this with some 'gentler' more caring relationships and
friendships that go beyond the expectations of the witch world.
Carolyn Hull