Love you two by Maria Pallotta-Chiarolli
Random House, 2008.
ISBN 9781741660715.
(Age 15+) Pallotta-Chiarolli won great acclaim in 2000 for her family
history Tapestry. Her new novel, Love You Two, continues to explore
themes of culture, heritage and relationships within the Italian
community she knows and understands.
Pina's voice is strong and courageous - she is independent but forever
faced with the deep seated, confining views of many of the older
generation in her family. One day Pina makes an extraordinary
discovery which tosses her views to the wind. Her steadiness is
shaken and she runs away to stay with a favourite uncle. Here her
world is thrust about again with another discovery about the nature of
her family.
It seems as if Pina is teetering on the edge of a cliff - how will she
unravel these family secrets and what consequences will they have for
her life?
Pallotta-Chiarolli's characters are well drawn - strong and
memorable. It is easy to become part of Pina's world, experience
her confusion, frustration and heart ache. The Italian flavour of
the story is well conceived - humorous asides at the Italian way of
life sit alongside a deep respect for its culture. There is also
a strong sense of needing to recognise Italian life in a modern world
and to be accepting of changing attitudes. Life in these
communities in Australian cities can be a battle for many, for many and
complex reasons.
The book confronts these problems well, though the subject matter may
be too large for the scope of the story. Palotta-Chiarolli's
issue is with recognising the array of possible relationships in a
family without discrimination - I sense that she tries to encompass too
much here - the storyline becomes contrived and unbelievable in parts.
The subjects of gender, sexual and family diversity make this a mature
read.
Julie Wells