Stay where you are and then leave by John Boyne
Random House, 2013. ISBN 9780857532947.
Set in London on the eve of the First World War, the close, loving
family comprising five year old Alfie, his mother Margie and father
Georgie is warmly presented in the introduction to this story. These
are simple people with limited expectations and aspirations, yet
they work hard and care deeply for one another.
Working for the dairy, Georgie drives a horse drawn cart from house
to house delivering milk and Alfie's greatest dream is to join him
on his rounds. The occasion of his fifth birthday should be one of
celebration, yet apart from Granny Summerfield , aged neighbour
Bill, best friend Kalena and her father, all guests cancel at the
last minute due to the declaration of war with Germany. Alfie is
disappointed but his life falls apart when his father enlists in the
army a few days later.
Complex notions of service to Crown and country versus conscientious
objection, responsibility to family in the face of societal
expectations and living with accusations of cowardice are elements
which are explored and depicted by the author. Detention of
potential enemies also features.
The naivety of Alfie's perspective on this calamitous event
involving international politics and armed conflict helps mirror the
simplistic attitudes of young men who eagerly joined the fray.
Living in an era of industrial exploitation, it seems absurd that so
many rushed to join the ranks of those who would serve the needs of
politicians, incapable military leaders and capitalists who profited
shamelessly from the carnage. This novel helps us to reconsider
modern points of view developed with the luxury of hindsight ,
comfortable living standards and security from war. As Alfie was
powerless under the control of benevolent parents, soldiers who
enlisted and those later conscripted to take play a part in this
previously unimagined horror were equally without capacity to alter
destiny.
Alfie's and Georgie's relationship is particularly poignant because
Georgie has explained that he became the 'man of the house' at an
early age when his father was killed in a mining accident. Both
understand that the loss of a breadwinner means unending financial
hardship and misery for a family.
Four years later, Georgie's letters have become fewer and those
which do arrive are nonsensical before they stop completely. Alfie's
mother perpetuates the myth that he is serving on a secret operation
yet Alfie, a boy with shrewd intelligence beyond his years seeks
truth. An unnecessarily contrived coincidence whilst working as a
shoe shine boy provides Alfie with the information he needs to
discover what has really happened to his father and he encounters a
reality which is rarely the subject of adolescent fiction.
Rob Welsh