The matchbox diary by Paul Fleischman
Ill. by Bacham Ibatouline. Candlewick Press, 2013. ISBN 0 7636 4601
1.
(Age: 5+) Warmly recommended. Picture book. Immigration. With a
finely detailed illustrative technique, Ibatouline enhances the
story of one man's journey to the United States of America. With his
family he left impoverished Italy, going to join their father in the
USA, who had gone ahead. They wanted to provide opportunities for
their children, opportunities they would not have had staying in
Italy. His story is retold to his granddaughter, but not through a
diary but through the match boxes, each of which has an object
inside which elicits a story from the old man. Unable to read or
write he collected objects from his old life, his journey, his home
in the USA and his eventual success. Inside the old cigar box
are dozens of match boxes, each with a story to tell.
We hear of the olive pip, given by his mother to suck to alleviate
the hunger pains in the children. A small brooch fell from the upper
deck on the ship bound to Ellis Island, and this was kept to remind
him of the voyage with its separation of rich and poor. In another
is a ticket to a baseball game, a sport they did not understand at
first, but went along to better fit themselves for their new life. A
tale is told of suffering, of privation, of finding a home and
success in their new home. With hints of prejudice, the family
succeeds.
The almost monochrome illustrations cover the pages, drawing the eye
to the amazing amount of detail, and supporting the text
beautifully, colour coming into the pages when the man is with his
granddaughter, passing on the family stories to her.
The setting of the USA and its post war migration is a different
slant on the theme of new arrivals and one which will find a home in
schools where migration, immigration and new arrivals is a topic to
be discussed. The pages where prejudice is shown to the family will
resonate with many who have left their home to come to a new land,
and will too be a discussion point in classrooms. The award winning
author and artist duo have produced a book which will be picked up
by students in the library and taken to classes where these themes
are discussed.
Fran Knight