The Odyssey retold by Gillian Cross
Ill. by Neil Packer. Walker Books, 2012. ISBN 9781406303674.
(Age: 9+) Recommended. Greek myths. Reading a new edition of The
Odyssey is like meeting an old friend. The stories are the
same, although the rendering of them slightly different, the
illustrations new and unusual, but at its heart it is familiar and
evokes comfort. So the tale of Odysseus trying to return home after
ten long years at war with Troy, is full of the stories of Cyclops
and Circe, the Sirens, Penelope rejecting her unwanted suitors,
Poseidon's winds, Calypso and more, while at its heart it tells of
man's battle against the whim of the Gods and his own frailties.
If Odysseus had not taunted Cyclops after escaping his island,
perhaps his father Poseidon, would not have called the winds to cast
the boat upon the seas, perhaps if Odysseus' men had not been
suspicious and opened the bag of winds then nine years of sailing
the seas would not have been wasted, perhaps if they had not upset
the Gods, then the men on his boat would have been able to sail
safely home. Reading these again, I was struck again by the frailty
of men, the fragility of their existence, their dependence on
cunning and guile to get them through, the strength of character
usually shown by Odysseus, and that of his wife Penelope, in
rejecting the suitors crowding at her door. And this retelling flows
beautifully.
In illustrating these beautiful old stories, Packer has used a
variety of techniques, rendering the pictures accompanying the tales
with a mixture of collage, line drawings, sometimes emulating the
Greek vases and their drawings, shadow pictures and outlines, or
using black with great effect. Whatever technique is used the
illustrations give details which reflect the story well. I love the
illustrations giving a family tree, outlining the Gods and their
relationships with each other as they appear on the scene, and the
map showing the seas traversed by Odysseus and his men, as well as
the illustrations on the front and back of the slip cover on this
impressively produced hard cover book. The thicker pages are durable
and strong, allowing for lots of little and big hands to open and
read, for teachers to read aloud, for people to borrow and read at
home, marvelling at the sepia tones presented on each page.
reminding us all over again that this is an old story, one passed
down through the ages, told and read over millenia, and here
tantalisingly re-offered.
Fran Knight