The Scandalous Sisterhood of Prickwillow Place by Julie Berry
Piccadilly Press, 2015. ISBN 9781848124370
(Age: 10+) Recommended. Humour. Mystery. When their headmistress and
her brother are murdered, Smooth Kitty and her six fellow students
decide to keep it a secret. They bury the bodies in the vegetable
garden and dress up Stout Alice in the headmistress' place. But
there is still a murderer on the prowl.
This is very funny take on a murder mystery and on the tradition of
the farce genre. Each of the seven girls are named in such a way
that the reader can keep in touch with their personality and
appearance - although the amusing illustrations on the front cover
and inside the book help as well. Smooth Kitty is the ring leader of
the plot and she is the one who comes up with the ideas while having
the ability to smooth over difficulties and tell smooth lies.
Disgraceful Mary Jane is very pretty and loves to flirt madly with
any young boy or man nearby. Stout Alice is plump but has the
ability to act really well and to mimic other people's voices so she
is perfect to pretend that she is Constance Plackett, the
headmistress that the girls disliked. Pocked Louis has been marked
by small pox when young, but she makes up her appearance with her
brains and scientific ability. Dour Elinor always thinks the worst
and is quite interested in death, while Dear Roberta is kind hearted
and Dull Martha is not the brightest of children.
Set against a background of 1890, when young girls were expected to
be prepared for marriage, even if they yearned to do more with their
lives, the book romps along as the seven girls find their feet
without adult supervision. Amid many moments of hilarity each girl
displays her strengths and weaknesses, learning a lot about
themselves and each other in the process. Underlying this is a
thread of tension, as the reader tries to work out how the murders
were committed and who might have a motive, all the while knowing
that Stout Alice masquerading as the headmistress has been placed in
grave danger.
A very enjoyable, feel good book that celebrates the different types
of personalities of the girls and the friendships that hold them
together The Scandalous Sisterhood of Prickwillow will be
appreciated by readers who like a historical mystery with unusual
in-depth characterisation.
Pat Pledger