The Yoga Ogre by Peter Bently & Simon Rickerty
Simon and Schuster, ISBN: 978 1 84738 902 2.
Ogden the Ogre is an ogre whose pyjamas have grown too short and too
tight. He's confused as to what's happened, but there is strong
allusion to the fact that it might be down to the 12 meals a day he
eats. The people suggest that he should take up a sport, and he
tries many different activities, including basketball, soccer,
hockey, horse riding, golf, and finally, yoga.
The people don't like the results of Ogden's enthusiasm, as it
results in the destruction of their town. They advise him to give up
on sport all together, and react with horror and dread when he
doesn't listen.
This is a stylistically lovely book, with vibrant and bright
colours. The people, and Ogden, are drawn with skill and expression,
and the medium is reminiscent of a child's crayon drawings, which
might make the illustrations more relatable and accessible to
children.
The text is full of rollicking and amusing rhymes, and the book is a
pleasant read aloud. The language is expressive and the vocabulary
choices are interesting without being too florid. There was much I
wanted to love about this book.
I can't however let this review go by without commenting on some of
the more subversively shaming themes and language used by the
author. As a mother, I found it alarming that a children's book
would be so openly judgemental of a character based on their weight.
From the very first page, when Ogden is told 'Overweight ogres
should take up a sport', there is a theme that Ogden is larger than
average, and that this isn't OK. Many parents I know would not be OK
with wording such as 'overweight,' 'diet' and, perhaps most
alarmingly 'I'll have to find some other way to get thinner'.
I think, had the author made the people in the story more supportive
of Ogden's effort, the tone of the book would be different. However,
no matter what sport Ogden tries, the people or animals run from
him, hide, or openly be dismissive of his efforts. It's an
alarmingly oppressive message to send to a young reader, especially
when the commonly accepted wisdom from medical and child development
experts is that food should not be presented as 'good' or 'bad' and
that exercise and healthy eating should take precedent over striving
for a certain size, dieting, etc.
Freya Lucas