We were liars by E. Lockhart
Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781760111069.
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. Wealth and power. Greed.
Psychological injury. Truth and lies. Poignantly powerful and full
of suspense, this book takes the reader through the distress of a
major psychological incident to uncover the truth and lies at its
heart. The central characters are born to wealth and privilege in
USA, living in wealthy Boston and spending indolent summers on the
family island near Martha's Vineyard. The greed and self-focus that
hides underneath the impeccable outer veneer of lies, gives a view
to the world of aspirational perfection which is, in fact, far from
perfect. The reader is introduced to this world through the eyes of
the psychologically damaged teenager, Cadence, who is struggling to
remember her past. Her story and the unveiling of her 15th summer
lost in the fog of amnesia, is woven with fairy-tale and literature
stories of comparison. This weaving creates a beautiful association,
leaving the reader aware of the dark and light of the narrative in
the completed tapestry of We were liars. As is the case with
all good suspense stories, the ending should only be known by those
who are prepared to get to know the whole story and read the book.
This would make an excellent film script.
I can highly recommend this book for mature readers. It is
beautifully written, with a coming of age undertone, and also a
moral tale with an unstated but implicit criticism of the
consequences of great wealth within a family. I especially enjoyed
the simplicity of sentence structure at the end of many chapters.
This writing style choice is intelligent and perfect in revealing
inside the mind of the central character.
[There is a small section within the book with swearing that may
make this difficult for more conservative school libraries, but for
readers 15+, this language choice is not surprising in context.]
Carolyn Hull