What makes us by Rafi Mittlefehldt
Candlewick Press, 2019. ISBN: 9780763697501.
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Eran is a passionate student who
believes in standing up for social justice. His discussions with his
teacher Mr Riskin explore the boundaries of when violence is
necessary and legitimate and when it becomes terrorism. Eran is
leading a protest against increased police powers to stop and
arrest. He believes that his anger is a justified response to
oppressive forces, and in moments of conflict he refuses to bow
down, he always rises to the fight. And that is what happens, in a
split second, when a counter protest meets with the student group,
and a belligerent bearded guy provokes him, Eran reacts with a push.
The man falls backward, and suddenly Eran's mother, Eema, is there
before the news cameras saying 'This is not our fight'.
That moment changes Eran's life. An astute reporter makes the
connection between Eema's words and an incident 15 years earlier
when a Jewish terrorist blew up a group of people and himself. The
Jewish terrorist was Eran's father, the man who left them when he
was only a toddler. Suddenly Eran comes face-to-face with his hidden
identity, and obsesses over whether he has the same violent
tendencies, and whether his anger is part of his genetic
inheritance. Can anger be justified? Can it be a good thing? Or is
it something that is always going to get him into trouble?
The issue of anger and anger management is explored thoughtfully in
the novel, as the tide of community anger turns against Eran and his
mother, the supposed terrorists in their midst. It is a new young
friend, Jade, also discovering hidden secrets in her family, who is
finally able to provide the calmness and insight that Eran needs.
The descriptions of the community's blind violence towards the
perceived 'other', the Jewish terrorists, is very powerful, and is a
reminder of the destructiveness of ignorance and prejudice, the kind
of prejudice that currently often has expression towards Muslim
people in our society. Mittlefehldt's novel is a very clever and
thoughtful exploration of the issues, and deserves to be included in
school discussions of racism, bigotry and terrorism. The book is so
well written, I am sure that teenagers will readily identify with
the character of Eran and the dilemma he faces. It is also
encouraging to see the portrayal of a caring and involved teacher,
Mr Riskin, who tries to interrogate some of the fear and anger that
Eran carries. And the loyalty and friendship between the young
students is also another strong positive value throughout the book.
There is much to think about and enjoy in this book. I can highly
recommend it to teenage and adult readers.
Helen Eddy