When I was me by Hilary Freeman
Hot Key Books, 2015. ISBN: 9781471404924
(Age: 15+) Story: Yesterday, Ella's life was completely normal.
Today, she woke up as a different person. Or, to be more exact, she
feels like the same person, but she looks different, her friends are
different, and every facet of her life is different to what she
remembers. At first she thinks she must be crazy, especially since
she's the only person who thinks that anything is wrong, but when
she meets a stranger named Daniel, she starts drawing closer and
closer to the truth . . .
Review: First things first: When I was me is actually a good
book. It has an intriguing, very original plotline, some interesting
characters, and tremendous amounts of potential. However, this
potential is never fully achieved - despite being very promising at
first, this book ends up just sitting squarely within the genre
of 'teen romance'. While not a bad thing necessarily, the
intrigue of the original idea - that of a girl waking up in a life
that is not hers, and all the consequences of that - almost feels
wasted here. One feels that Freeman could have easily made this into
a complex thriller with a dash of science-fiction sensibilities, but
instead the book remains simple - at times far too much - and
becomes just another run-of-the-mill teen novel rife with romance
and friendship dramas. This is not to say the novel is totally
flawed, however - there are some excellent themes here at play, and
Freeman deals deftly with complicated topics such as finding your
identity, and how we perceive reality. The characters are
interesting, yet ultimately underdeveloped, and it rollicks along at
an exciting pace. But while this novel is definitely enjoyable, it
never quite reaches the heights it could have, and ultimately,
that's the most frustrating thing.
Rebecca Adams (university student)